Top 10 Rare Firearms Sold at Rock Island Auction

Key Takeaways:

• The stories behind the steel matter just as much as the steel itself: It’s not just about rare guns — it’s about why they’re rare. The Colt that rode west with a ranger, the Garand that maybe saw Normandy — provenance and history aren’t just details. They’re the heartbeat of value.
• Rock Island Auction is more than a place to buy things — it’s a place to belong: Collectors don’t just show up to spend money. They show up to talk, connect, learn, argue, and geek out. It’s a weirdly welcoming corner of the world where history buffs, investors, and dreamers all share the same table.
• Firearm collecting is evolving, but the passion is still the same: Sure, online bidding is changing the game, and the definition of “collectible” keeps expanding. But one thing hasn’t changed: people still crave that moment when a piece of history becomes theirs.

These aren’t just expensive. These are legendary.

1. The Colt Walker — The Unicorn of the West

If the American West had a flagship firearm, it’d be the Colt Walker. These were massive, powerful revolvers designed for the Texas Rangers in the mid-1800s, and only about 1,100 were manufactured. Most didn’t survive frontier life. The one sold at Rock Island? Near mint. Historic. A collector’s holy grail. It brought in millions — literally.

2. The Borchardt C-93 — Before the Luger, There Was This

You’ve probably never handled one, but the Borchardt C-93 is like the grandfather of all modern semi-auto pistols. Weird, boxy, mechanical — but pure genius. Designed in the 1890s, it was ahead of its time. The example sold at auction was in pristine condition. The kind of thing a museum would fight over. Except that a private collector won.

3. Winchester Model 1873 — “The Gun That Won the West”

This one’s a classic. If Hollywood had a favorite rifle, this would be it. The Winchester 1873 isn’t rare in and of itself — they made a bunch — but condition and provenance change everything. The one that crossed the block at Rock Island? Mint condition. Likely never saw a day on the prairie. And the price it fetched? Proof that stories still sell.

4. Luger P08 — German Engineering, Collector Obsession

There’s just something about a Luger. That toggle-lock action, that sleek grip — it’s instantly recognizable. Collectors go nuts over the variations, especially early ones or models with war ties. Rock Island featured a near-flawless example with matching numbers and historic documentation. The kind of piece that pulls five figures with ease.

5. Spencer Repeating Rifle — The Game-Changer

Many people are unaware of the revolutionary impact Spencer had during the Civil War. Soldiers could fire multiple rounds without reloading after every shot — a huge deal back then. The rifle that was sold at auction? Exceptional condition, rich provenance. The kind of piece that makes Civil War buffs weak in the knees.

6. Colt Paterson — Where It All Began

This is the revolver that started it all — literally. Samuel Colt’s first big production model. They’re delicate, a bit funky looking, and nearly impossible to find intact. The one at Rock Island was beautifully preserved. It felt like stepping into 1836, right there on the auction block.

7. Smith & Wesson Model 3 — Old West Royalty

Before S&W became a household name, they were making top-break revolvers like this one. The Model 3 was a favorite of both lawmen and outlaws. Wyatt Earp carried one. The example auctioned off? Pristine, nickel-plated, engraved — pure Americana. It’s the kind of gun that makes even non-collectors lean in for a closer look.

8. Sharps Rifle — Long Range, Long History

Sharps rifles were renowned for their exceptional accuracy — buffalo hunters, military sharpshooters, and even Civil War marksmen all appreciated them. The one sold at Rock Island had all the bells and whistles: target sights, rich patina, original wood. The kind of firearm that tells its own story even when no one’s speaking.

9. Mauser C96 “Broomhandle” — So Ugly It’s Beautiful

This pistol resembles one that would be found on a steampunk movie set. But don’t let the weird shape fool you — the C96 was revolutionary—internal box mag, shoulder stock, central power. Winston Churchill supposedly carried one. The one sold here? Immaculate. Still had its wood stock holster—collector gold.

10. M1 Garand — The Rifle That Won a War

You’ve probably heard the phrase “the greatest battle implement ever devised.” That was Gen. Patton, talking about the M1 Garand. WWII vets carried them. So did the GIs storming Normandy. The Garand sold here wasn’t just any rifle — it was a historically significant piece, likely tied to an elite unit. Gorgeous condition, too.

Who’s Buying These Things?

Collectors. Dreamers. Historians. Folks who just really, really like well-made things.

Some of them are chasing childhood obsessions. Others are investing — betting that the market for rare guns will keep climbing. A few love the hunt. Whatever their reason, they come ready to spend — and Rock Island brings the goods.

One minute you’re talking to a dentist from Ohio. Next, a retired Marine bidding on a revolver, he swears he carried a version of in Iraq. There’s a quiet intensity to it, but also camaraderie. People clap when a big sale goes through. Even if they just lost the bid.

Why Rock Island Matters (Beyond the Price Tags)

Let’s zoom out for a second.

What Rock Island Auction does — and does well — is preserve stories. Guns, for better or worse, are tied to some of the most significant moments in human history. Wars. Revolutions. Expansions. Law and order. Chaos and rebellion. They’re not just tools; they’re time machines.

And by curating, documenting, and selling these firearms, Rock Island keeps those stories alive. They also hold the standard high — authenticity, provenance, and research. No shortcuts.

Thinking About Bidding? Here’s What You Should Know

First time dipping your toe into this world? A few things:

• Read the catalog. Seriously. It’s packed with info, condition grades, and provenance details.
• Set a budget. And maybe stick to it. Easy to get swept up when the bidding starts flying.
• Use the preview days. If you can go in person, do it. Photos only go so far.
• Ask questions. The staff know their stuff and love to talk shop.

And remember: it’s not just about winning. It’s about the ride. The people. The stories.

What’s Next for Auctions Like These?

The world’s changing. Fast. But oddly enough, the rare gun market? Still strong.

Online bidding has opened the door for more people to participate, and collectors are getting younger. Interest is shifting toward 20th-century military arms, Cold War stuff, even some modern oddities with a story behind them. It’s not just about flintlocks and dueling pistols anymore.

That said, the hunger for historical, one-of-a-kind firearms? Still going strong. And Rock Island? Still leading the charge.

So, whether you’re a seasoned bidder, a curious newcomer, or just someone who likes the smell of old gun oil and adventure, something is captivating about this world. And at Rock Island Auction, that world comes to life.

Steel, stories, and a whole lot of heart.

Frequently Asked Questions